Skip to content
Blackshore Agency

When SaaS Stops Fitting: 7 Signs Your Business Has Outgrown Off-the-Shelf Software

Off-the-shelf software stops fitting when the cost of working around it exceeds the cost of owning the workflow. Seven signs the tools you rent no longer match the business you run — and how to run the five-year comparison before you decide.

By Published 5 min read

Contents

The short answer

Off-the-shelf software stops fitting when the cost of working around it exceeds the cost of owning the workflow. That moment rarely announces itself. It shows up as a renewal nobody remembers approving, a spreadsheet bridging two tools that were supposed to talk to each other, and a monthly bill that rises every time you hire.

If two or three of the signs below sound familiar, the question is no longer whether SaaS works in general. It is whether the specific tools you rent still match the business you run now.

1. You are paying for seats nobody uses

Zylo's 2025 SaaS Management Index found that 53% of SaaS licences go unused in an average 30-day period, adding up to an average of $21 million in wasted spend per organisation each year. The waste is not a rounding error. It is the largest leak in most software budgets, and it recurs every month because licences drift each time someone joins, leaves, or changes role.

Count active users per tool, not purchased seats. Any tool with under half its seats active is a candidate for rightsizing — or for replacement by something built around the people who actually use it.

2. New tools arrive faster than old ones leave

The average company now holds 275 applications in its portfolio, according to the same Zylo index, with an average of seven new apps entering the environment every month. And 84% of applications sit outside IT's responsibility, bought by individual teams on cards and expense reports.

Every new tool adds a renewal date, a login, a data silo, and a vendor relationship. Nobody's job is to retire tools, so the stack only grows. If you cannot list every application your business pays for, from one place, you do not have a software strategy. You have a pile of subscriptions.

3. The workaround has become the workflow

Watch for the manual bridges: the spreadsheet that reconciles two systems, the weekly export-and-fix routine, the copy-paste between tabs that one employee does because the tools never learned to talk. Each workaround starts as a five-minute favour and hardens into a permanent job.

Workarounds are the clearest signal that a tool no longer fits the process. The process is real; the tool is rented. When the gap between them is filled by human effort every day, you are paying twice — once for the subscription, once in staff time. Start with the workarounds that eat the most hours: automate the boring work first.

4. You use a third of what you bought

Gartner's 2023 survey of 405 marketing leaders found they used just 33% of their martech stack's capability on average, down from 42% in 2022 and 58% in 2020. The stack got bigger every year; the share actually used kept falling.

The same dynamic shows up well beyond marketing. Vendors sell capability in bundles, and teams buy the bundle for the two features they need. A tool built for your workflow has no unused two-thirds, because there is nothing in it you did not ask for.

5. The per-seat bill grows faster than the business

Zylo puts average SaaS spend at $4,830 per employee per year. For a 40-person company that is $193,200 a year — before add-ons, premium tiers, and renewal increases. Every hire raises the software bill automatically, whether or not the new person needs the full stack.

Custom software inverts that curve. The build is a fixed cost, and adding a user costs close to nothing. That is why the per-seat model punishes growing companies hardest: the more people you add, the more you pay for the same workflow.

6. Your process is the differentiator

Some software is a commodity — payroll, email, standard accounting — and buying it is almost always right. But when the software runs the thing that makes your business different — your pricing, your client onboarding, the workflow your customers actually experience — renting a generic version means running your advantage on someone else's roadmap.

Ask one question per tool: does this handle a standard process, or does it run our edge? Standard processes should be bought. The edge is worth owning, because a vendor will never prioritise your differentiator over their next thousand customers.

7. Renewals surprise you

Companies renew an average of 247 SaaS applications a year, according to Zylo — roughly one every business day. Automatic renewal clauses mean the decision to keep paying is made for you, in the background, unless someone is watching the calendar.

A stack you cannot govern is a stack you cannot budget. If renewals land as surprises, the problem is not discipline. It is that the portfolio has outgrown the attention anyone can give it.

The honest comparison: five years, not year one

The most common error in build-versus-buy analysis is comparing the upfront cost of building against the first year of buying. Stretch both over five years, and count everything: subscriptions and per-seat growth, implementation and integration, workaround labour, maintenance, hosting, and exit costs.

The numbers below are an illustrative example with stated assumptions, not a quote: a 100-person company, one core workflow tool at $60 per user per month, a custom build at $150,000, maintenance at 15% of build cost per year, hosting at $5,000 per year.

  • Buy: 100 users × $60 × 12 months = $72,000 a year, or $360,000 over five years — before price increases, add-ons, or headcount growth.
  • Build: $150,000 build + $112,500 maintenance (15% × 5 years) + $25,000 hosting = $287,500 over five years — and the cost barely moves as headcount grows.

At 20 users the same arithmetic flips the other way: buying costs $72,000 over five years, far below any build. Scale decides the answer, which is why the comparison has to be run on your numbers, not on a vendor's first-year price.

One more line belongs in the comparison: people. The median annual wage for a software developer was $135,980 in May 2025, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics — before benefits. Hiring in-house to build and maintain custom software is the expensive route for most firms this size, which is why a software engineering retainer is the usual way smaller companies own custom software: a fixed monthly slice of a senior team, instead of a full-time hire.

What to do next

  1. List every tool you pay for, what it costs, and how many people actively use it. One afternoon, one spreadsheet.
  2. Score each tool: commodity or differentiator?
  3. For the differentiators with chronic workarounds, run the five-year comparison above on your real numbers.
  4. Before you decide, talk to someone who has made the call before. The case for a fractional technology leader explains what that conversation looks like — or bring us the list and we will run the comparison with you.

Questions

Is custom software always cheaper than SaaS?

No. At small scale, buying wins easily — 20 users at $60 a month costs $72,000 over five years, far below any build. Custom software wins when headcount is large enough that per-seat pricing compounds, or when the workflow is a differentiator that generic tools force you to work around.

How do I know if a process is a differentiator?

Ask whether the process is how your business wins customers or delivers its edge. Payroll, email, and standard accounting are commodities — buy them. Your pricing, client onboarding, or the workflow customers experience is the edge — that is worth owning.

What should a build-vs-buy comparison include?

Both options over three to five years: subscription fees and per-seat growth, implementation and integration, workaround labour, maintenance (typically 15–20% of build cost per year), hosting, and exit costs. Comparing a build's upfront cost against one year of subscriptions is the most common error.

Sources

  1. Zylo — IT Strategy: 5 Stats That Prove You Need SaaS Management (2025 SaaS Management Index)
  2. Gartner — Survey Finds 63% of Marketing Leaders Plan to Invest in Generative AI (2023 martech utilization)
  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics — Software Developers, Quality Assurance Analysts, and Testers (median wage $135,980, May 2025)
  4. Hatcha — Build vs buy: when custom software makes sense

Perspectives is published by BlackShore Agency. The views expressed are those of the firm.

Continue the conversation

What would this mean for your organization?

Related reading

All perspectives →

Subscribe

Perspectives, delivered.

New thinking from the firm, sent when there is something worth reading. Never more.